Sunday, February 17, 2019

The hydroelectric threat to the Amazon basin

The Belo Monte dam under construction, revealing the devastation of the river valley and surrounding forest. © Lalo de Almeida
The Belo Monte dam under construction, revealing the devastation of the river valley and surrounding forest. © Lalo de Almeida

Abstract

For decades hydroelectric power was seen as the solution to Latin America’s energy needs. However, serious questions have arisen over its long-term viability. Ecologists warn of the potentially catastrophic impact of dams on the Amazon basin, the most complex network of river channels in the world.

 

Dams have also had hugely damaging impacts on indigenous and riverine communities. Moreover, major hydro projects have been plagued by massive corruption.

Index

About the Authors

Marilene Ribeiro is an award-winning photographer and ecologist whose works investigate the relationship between human beings and nature concerning contemporary issues. She holds an MSc in Ecology and Wildlife Conservation and Management from the Federal University of Minas Gerais (Brazil), and a PhD in photography from the University of Brighton (UK). Marilene’s works approach global issues seen through the lens of Brazil.

Sue Branford is a journalist who reported from Brazil for over a decade. A founding member of LAB’s editorial team, she has worked for the BBC, the Financial Times, The Guardian and The Economist. She has written five books on Latin America, mainly on Brazil. Her latest book, co-authored with Maurício Torres, titled Amazon Besieged: by dams, soya, agribusiness and land grabbing (Practical Action Publishing and LAB 2018).

Interviewees

Leonardo Batista, aka Aronor, Brazil. © Leonardo Batista and Marilene Cardoso Ribeiro 2016

Leonardo Batista, aka Aronor (Ribeirinho Council): interviewed in Altamira, Pará, Brazil, on 14 October 2016 by Marilene Cardoso Ribeiro. Transcribed by Karina Ribeiro and translated by Paula Coppio, Edgar Refinetti, and Diego Satyro.

Maria Eliete Felix Juruna, Brazil. © Maria Eliete Felix Juruna and Marilene Cardoso Ribeiro 2016

Maria Eliete Felix Juruna (Paquiçamba Indigenous Reserve): interviewed in Paquiçamba, Pará, Brazil, on 6 November 2016 by Marilene Cardoso Ribeiro.

Transcribed by Karina Ribeiro and translated by Chris Whitehouse.144 VOICES OF LATIN AMERICA

Antônia Melo, Brazil. © Verena Glass 2017 / International Rivers

Antônia Melo (Movimento Xingu Vivo para Sempre): interviewed in Altamira, Pará, Brazil, in early September 2015 by Eliane Brum. Translated by Hugo Moss.

Maria Rosa Pessoa Piedade (ribeirinha at Palhau): interviewed in Altamira, Pará, Brazil, on 2 November 2016 by Marilene Cardoso Ribeiro. Transcribed by Karina Ribeiro and translated by Alistair Clark.

References

Aleixo, J. and Condé, N. (2015) Quem são os proprietários das hidrelétricas da Amazônia?, Instituto Mais Democracia, Rio de Janeiro.

Branford, S. (2016) ‘BNDES has long history of loans to gigantic construction companiesMongabay, 14 March

Branford, S. (2018) ‘Brazil announces end to Amazon mega-dam building policy’, Mongabay, 3 January

Brum, E. (2015) ‘O dia em que a casa foi expulsa de casa’, El País, 14 September

Fearnside, P.M. (2015) Hidrelétricas na Amazônia – impactos ambientais e sociais na tomada de decisões sobre grandes obras, 2 vols, Editora do INPA, Manaus.

Fearnside, P.M. (2017) ‘Brazil’s Belo Monte dam: lessons of an Amazonian resource struggle’, in McCoy (ed.), Die Erde Special Issue, ‘Resource Geographies: New Perspectives from South America’

FGV (2016) Indicadores de Belo Monte – um diálogo entre condicionantes do licencia-mento ambiental e o desenvolvimento local, Câmara Técnica de Monitoramento das Condicionantes da UHE Belo Monte (CT-05), Fundação Getúlio Vargas and Centro de Estudos em Sustentabilidade (FGV-EAESP), Rio de Janeiro.

Harari, I. (2018) ‘Ribeirinhos atingidos por Belo Monte exigem retomar seu território’, Amazônia, 14 February

Hurwitz, Z., Millikan, B., Monteiro, T. and Widmer, R. (2011) Mega projeto, mega riscos – análise de riscos para investidores no Complexo Hidrelétrico Belo Monte, Amigos da Terra – Amazônia Brasileira and International Rivers, São Paulo

Instituto de Enghenaria (2010), ‘Crítica ao Aproveitamento Hidrelétrico Belo Monte’, Opinião, Jornal do Instituto de Enghenaria, Brasil, No.59, July

ISA (Instituto Socioambiental) (2016) Belo Monte: um legado de violações

Latrubesse, E.M., Arima, E.Y., Dunne, T., Park, E., Baker, V.R., d’Horta, F.M., Wight, C., Wittmann, F., Zuanon, J., Baker, P.A., Ribas, C.C., Norgaard, R.B., Filizola, N., Ansar, A., Flyvbjerg, B. and Stevaux, J.C. (2017) ‘Damming the rivers of the Amazon basin’, Nature 546(7658), 363–9.

Little, P. E. (2014) Mega-Development Projects in Amazonia: A Geopolitical and Socioenvironmental Primer, Red Jurídica Amazónica (RAMA), Derecho, Ambiente y Recursos Naturales (DAR), and Articulación Regional Amazónica (ARA), Lima.

MediaLivre (2011) ‘Belo Monte derruba presidente do Ibama pela II vez’, YouTube video, 14 January

MPF (Ministério Público Federal) (2013) ‘Ação civil pública no. 0000655-78.2013.4.01.3903’, issued on 19 April 2013.

MPF (2014) Plano Emergencial UHE Belo Monte, video directed by Marco Paulo Fróes Schettino, MPF, Altamira /Pará

MPF (2015) ‘Ação civil pública no. 3017-82.2015.4.01.3903’, issued on 10 December 2015.

Pérez, M.S. (2015) ‘Where the Xingu bends and will soon break’, American Scientist, November/December, 395–403

Pontes, F. (2011) ‘Belo Monte de violências’. Piseagrama 2, 16–20

Ribeiro, M.C. (2018) ‘Dead water – a photography-based inquiry into the impact of dams in Brazil’, University for the Creative Arts, Farnham [PhD thesis], slideshow

Santos, S.M.S.B.M. and Hernández, F.M. (organizers) (2009) Painel de especialistas – Análise crítica do estudo de impacto ambiental do aproveitamento hidrelétrico de Belo Monte, 29 October, Fundação Viver, Produzir e Preservar (FVPP) de Altamira, ISA, International Rivers Network (IRN), WWF, FASE, Rede de Justiça Ambiental, Belém

Sevá Filho, A.O. (2005) Tenotã-Mõ – alertas sobre as consequências dos projetos hidrelétricos no rio Xingu, IRN, São Paulo.

Sullivan, Z. (2016) ‘Brazil’s dispossessed: Belo Monte dam ruinous for indigenous cultures’, Mongabay, 8 December

Videos

Further reading

Further references:

Anderson, M. and Elkaim, A.V. (2018) ‘Belo Monte legacy: harm from Amazon dam didn’t end with construction (photo story)’, Mongabay, <https://news.mongabay.com/2018/02/belo-monte-legacy-harm-from-amazon-dam-didnt-end-with-construction>

Assahira, C; Piedade, M. T. F; Trumbore, S. E; Wittmann, F; Cintra, B. B. L.; Batista, E. S.; Resende, A. F. and Schöngart (2017) ‘Tree mortality of a flood-adapted species in response of hydrographic changes caused by an Amazonian river dam.’ Forest Ecology and Management, 396, pp. 113–123.

Baird, V. (2011) ‘Peru’s dam busters’, New Internationalist, <https://newint.org/features/2011/10/01/peru-ashaninka-pakitzapango-hydro-dam>

Barros, C. and Barcelos, I. (2017) ‘Battling a tide of sewage in Brazil: ‘For 17 days we lived with our feet under water’, The Guardian, <https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2017/dec/11/brazil-belo-monte-hydroelectric-dam-homes-battling-tide-sewage>

BBC News (2017) ‘Amazon culture clash over Brazil’s dams’, BBC News, <https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-38391377>

Benchimol, M. and Peres, C. A. (2015) ‘Widespread Forest Vertebrate Extinctions Induced by a Mega Hydroelectric Dam in Lowland Amazonia’, in PLoS ONE, 10 (7): e0129818. <https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0129818>

Branford, S. (2016) ‘Report from the Amazon: Altamira, a City Transformed by the Belo Monte Dam’, Amazon Watch, <https://amazonwatch.org/news/2016/0304-report-from-the-amazon-altamira-a-city-transformed-by-the-belo-monte-dam>

Branford, S. (2016) ‘BNDES funded Belo Monte dam — a mega-project with mega-problems’, Mongabay, <https://news.mongabay.com/2016/03/bndes-funded-belo-monte-dam-a-mega-project-with-mega-problems>

Claret, A. (2013) Chegou o inv(f)erno. São Paulo, Outras Expressões (priest Antônio Claret’s essays on the local effects of the Belo Monte dam project (in Portuguese)

Friedman, U. (2014) ‘The Woman Who Breaks Mega-Dams’, The Atlantic, <https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/04/the-woman-who-fights-dams/361352>

Fundação Getúlio Vargas (2015) ‘Indicadores de Belo Monte’, <http://indicadoresdebelomonte.eco.br> (project monitoring to what extent Belo Monte has satisfied the conditions of its environmental licence, as well as effectiveness of related public policy, in Portuguese)

Fundación Proteger, International Rivers and ECOA (n.d.) ‘Dams in Amazonia’, <http://dams-info.org/en> (interactive website that provides data on dam projects within the Amazon region)

Hill, D. (2015) ‘Peru planning to dam Amazon’s main source and displace 1000s’, The Guardian, <https://www.theguardian.com/environment/andes-to-the-amazon/2015/may/26/peru-amazon-main-source-dams-displacements>

Hill, D. (2015) ‘Peru’s mega-dam projects threaten Amazon River source and ecosystem collapse’, Mongabay, <https://news.mongabay.com/2015/04/perus-mega-dam-projects-threaten-amazon-river-source-and-ecosystem-collapse>

International Rivers (2012) ‘Belo Monte: Massive dam project strikes at the heart of the Amazon’, International Rivers <https://www.internationalrivers.org/sites/default/files/attached-files/Belo_Monte_FactSheet_May2012.pdf>

internationalrivers (2010) ‘Defending the Rivers of the Amazon, with Sigourney Weaver’, YouTube, <https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=621&v=Melq7VA7FjY>

Lees, A.C.; Peres, C. A.; Fearnside, P. M.; Schneider, M. and Zuanon, J. A. S. (2016) ‘Hydropower and the future of Amazonian biodiversity’, in Biodiversity Conservation, 25, pp. 451–466.

Moraes, M. and Pimentel, S. (2013) Amazônia Pública, São Paulo, Pública, 1st ed (in Portuguese)

MPF PA (2015) ‘Impactos Plano Emergencial Belo Monte’, YouTube, <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvyvyXVvmx0&feature=youtu.be> (directed by Marco Paulo Fróes, in Portuguese)

Nilsson, C.; Reidy, C. A.; Dynesius, M. and Revenga, C. (2005) ‘Fragmentation and flow regulation of the world’s large river systems’, in: Science, 308, pp. 405–408

Poirier, C. (2017) ‘Xingu River Defender Antônia Melo Honored for Her Lifelong Struggle’, Amazon Watch, <https://amazonwatch.org/news/2017/1011-xingu-river-defender-antonia-melo-honored-for-her-lifelong-struggle>

Poirier, C. (2017) ‘Victory for Indigenous Rights in Brazil as Court Revokes License for the Belo Sun Mine’, Amazon Watch, <https://amazonwatch.org/news/2017/1211-victory-for-indigenous-rights-in-brazil-as-court-revokes-license-for-the-belo-sun-mine>

Pontes Jr, Felício. (n.d.) ‘Belo Monte de Violências’, <http://belomontedeviolencias.blogspot.com/> (web blog by Felício Pontes Jr., a prosecutor for the State of Pará, in Portuguese)

Pskowski, M. (2016) ‘Dam opponents claim criminalization by Ecuadorian government’, Mongabay, <https://news.mongabay.com/2016/09/dam-opponents-claim-criminalization-by-ecuadorian-government>

Repórter Brasil (2015) ‘Cinzas de Belo Monte’, YouTube, <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AlY2Zkz-Hsk> (directed by Ana Aranha, in Portuguese)

Ribeiro, M.C. (2018) ‘Costs’, Vimeo, <https://vimeo.com/267872971> (in Portuguese with English subtitles)

TV Folha (2014) ‘A Batalha de Belo Monte – Especial TV Folha’, YouTube, <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CUqGWNYzSIQ> (in Portuguese)

YaleE360 (2017) ‘Belo Monte Dam: Conflict in the Amazon’, <https://vimeo.com/244671904>

Voices News

Filter news by:

Voices of Latin America — US edition

Voices of Latin America will be published in the US by Monthly Review Press, in partnership with LAB and Practical Action Publishing, in March 2019. Individual copies can be ordered from Monthly Review Press at US$32.00 each. Review copies can be ordered here (on the same page there is a link labelled 'desk copies', for professors who have already ordered a book for a class). Ingram Book Ordering here. Here is what US academics have said about Voices: Anthony Bebbington, Higgins Professor of Environment and Society, Clark University, Worcester, MA; Member of the Board of Directors, Oxfam America; Professorial Fellow, Global Development Institute, University...

Endorsements for Voices of Latin America

Here are some of the endorsements for LAB's new book, Voices of Latin America: Dr Duncan Green, Senior Strategic Adviser, OXFAM: This is a wonderful X-ray of modern Latin America, a vision of the continent's struggles and potential futures through the eyes of its social movement leaders and intellectuals. Read it from end to end, whether as an introduction or an update, or mine it for quotes from inspirational figures across the region on a range of contemporary issues. Latin America (or most of it) has come the end of its progressive 'pink tide' years of the early 2000s. For the...

Voices: a work in progress

Work on LAB's exciting new book Voices of Latin America is progressing rapidly More than 45 of our interviews, from 11 countries, have been translated, and our wonderful team of volunteer editors are at work on the separate chapters The editor and project co-ordinator is Tom Gatehouse Publication date is now set for September 2018 Alongside the book, we will develop the Voices website. This will include more interviews, photos, videos and some of the audio recordings used in the book. But it will be progressively added to to create a constantly growing and up-to-date archive of social...

Voices of Latin America: Thank you to all our generous supporters

We estimate that the total raised from our crowd-funding will be around £12,720 A huge thank you to all our generous supporters. Your pledges on our project Crowdfunding site totalled a magnificent £7,000. We have now received a further £4,000 from our match-funder. We can claim Gift Aid on most of those donations made by UK tax-payers, worth another 25%. This will enable us to pay for some of the daunting amount of editing and translation work and, if necessary, commission further Voices interviews. It's a big boost to the project.  

Voices of Latin America: crowd-funding completed… fund-raising continues

May 18. Our Crowdfunder campaign finished last night. We raised £7,000, but the total will be considerably more because part of this was match-funded. A huge thanks to our 163 generous supporters. It was a great learning experience for the LAB Voices team, and will be excellent advance promotion for the book. More funding needed If you missed the Crowdfunder deadline, it's not too late for you to contribute. Just go to the 'Donate with CAF' button on LAB's Home Page, or click here. Keep watching this space ...for updates on the project as it proceeds. We plan to begin adding audio, video,...